You’ve Gotta Try These 9 Amazing Eateries in Buffalo, NY

You’ve Gotta Try These 9 Amazing Eateries in Buffalo, NY
25 Aug 2023

Sharing is caring!

Are you planning a trip to Buffalo, New York, and looking for some great places to eat? You’re in luck – Buffalo is renowned for its amazing food! From classic comfort foods like beef on weck to classic Buffalo chicken wings, there’s something for everyone when it comes to experiencing all that Buffalo has to offer. Whether you are visiting the city as a tourist or just passing through on your way somewhere else, these spots offer an experience that lives up to their reputation of deliciousness.

Here are 9 amazing eateries you’ve got to try in Buffalo, New York:

swan street diner buffalo new york restaurants

Swan Street Diner

If you’re looking to taste a piece of Buffalo’s local history, Swan Street Diner should be at the top of your list. This popular fully restored 1937 diner car has provided decades worth of flavour and hospitality to those passing through or living in the area. Famous for its homemade pies and old-fashioned diner vibes, a trip to Swan Street Diner will leave you fully satisfied.

With its classic diner charm, jukebox tunes, and old-fashioned decor paired with fresh ingredients for its delicious dishes, it’s no wonder why so many locals continue to patronize this spot after all these years.

Suggested Menu Items

Biscuits & Gravy (house biscuit, house sausage gravy, over easy eggs), Eggs Benedict (English muffin, Canadian bacon, basted eggs, house hollandaise), or the House Hash (house corned beef, onion, home fries, two eggs, toast).

Location

Swan Street Diner is located at 700 Swan Street in Buffalo, NY.

Dinosaur BBQ

Do you love BBQ? Does the thought of juicy, tender ribs smothered in mouthwatering sauce get your taste buds tingling? Well, then a meal at Dinosaur BBQ in Buffalo is just what you need.

With its incredible southern smokehouse barbecue offerings, delicious sides, warm atmosphere, and just the right amount of country charm – this is one destination that nothing compares to!

So if you’re looking for something other than Buffalo chicken wings to spice up your vacation and fill those stomachs that are roaring for something good, look no further than Dinosaur BBQ in Buffalo.

Suggested Menu Items

Creole Deviled eggs (Cajun spiced, topped with chives), and the Combination Platter: choose your meats + 2 homemade sides, and cornbread. (Meats: Pulled Pork, St. Louis Ribs, BBQ Brisket with jalapenos, Jalapeno Cheddar Hot Link Sausage, Quarter Chicken, Quarter lb. Drunken Spicy Shrimp. Sides: BBQ Beans with pork, BBQ Fried Rice with BBQ meats, Fresh Cut Fries, Mac & Cheese, Simmered Greens with smoked turkey, Roasted Whipped Sweet Potatoes with nuts, Mashed Potatoes with gravy, Cajun Corn, Chopped Salad, Coleslaw, Harlem Potato Salad, or Applesauce.)

Location

Dinosaur BBQ Buffalo is located at 301 Franklin Street in Buffalo, NY.

Duff’s Famous Wings

When making plans for a visit to Buffalo, add Duff’s Famous Wings to the itinerary. This restaurant was established in 1969 and has become an iconic destination for Buffalo chicken wings. It’s easy to see why this eatery has become a local hotspot. With a warm atmosphere that hums with excitement, irresistible flavours of wing sauce, and other tasty menu items like their savoury sandwiches and salads available, it’s no wonder why Duff’s is one of Western New York’s most beloved restaurants.

Whether you’re visiting Buffalo or passing through on your way somewhere else, a stop at this classic establishment is sure to provide you with an unforgettable meal.

Suggested Menu Items

1 lb of Wings (with mild sauce or lemon pepper dry rub) and Duff’s Buffalo Shrimp (lightly breaded shrimp, smothered in any of our famous wing sauces, served with your choice of dipping sauce).

Locations

There are a few Duff’s Famous Wings locations in the Buffalo area:
3090 Orchard Park Drive, Buffalo, NY
3651 Sheridan Drive, Amherst, NY
550 Dick Road, Depew, NY
4545 Transit Road, Williamsville, NY

pearl street grill and brewery buffalo new york restaurants

Pearl Street Grill & Brewery

You won’t want to miss out on a trip to Buffalo if craft beer is your thing. Along the picturesque Pearl Street lies one of the city’s prime spots for great sudsy satisfaction, Pearl Street Grill & Brewery. Open since 1997, this classic brewpub features its own brewed beer and pub fare in an upbeat atmosphere complete with New Orleans-style wrap-around copper-roofed patios.

But it’s not just about the craft beer – they have a pretty awesome menu at this brewpub. From classic pub favourites like burgers and pizza, there is something for every appetite.

Whether you’re stopping by for a bite and tasting flight, or celebrating happy hour with some friends, be sure to check out what Pearl Street Grill & Brewery has on tap!

Suggested Menu Items

Pearl Street Pizza (homemade red sauce topped with shredded mozzarella, pepperoni, sausage, banana peppers, mushrooms, onions, and black olives), Giant Pretzel (served with gouda cheese sauce, Lake Effect Pale Ale Mustard and spicy horseradish sauce), Stuffed Banana Peppers (two chorizo sausage stuffed peppers smothered in marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese with pita wedges), or the Ditch Digger Burger (topped with thick double smoked bacon, cheddar, and onion rings on a brioche roll, with lettuce and tomato and served with pub fries). Wash it down with a Lake Effect (East Coast-style pale ale, 6.0 ABV 33 IBU), Sabres Edge (Double IPA, 7.75% ABV 64 IBU), Lighthouse (Light blonde ale, 3.9 ABV 7 IBU), or a Wild OX (American Style Wheat Beer, 4.65% ABV 8 IBU).

Location

Pearl Street Grill & Brewery is located at 76 Pearl Street in Buffalo, NY.

anchor bar buffalo new york restaurants

Anchor Bar

Are you a foodie looking for an unforgettable culinary experience? If so, then look no further than the original home of Buffalo chicken wings – Anchor Bar in Buffalo. This iconic establishment has been serving its famous crispy and spicy creations since 1964 and continues to provide fans from all over the world with their favourite wings.

Whether it’s game day grub or a late-night snack after bar hopping, the birthplace of the now-iconic spicy appetizer won’t let you down! Bring your appetite because this is one mouthwatering meal that must be tried firsthand to truly be appreciated.

Suggested Menu Items

Single order of Traditional Wings (tossed in mild Anchor Bar Wing Sauce), Fried Coconut Shrimp (shrimp is coated in a coconut breadcrumb and quickly fried to perfection), and the Pizza Logs (egg roll wraps stuffed with mozzarella cheese and pepperoni, served with a side of pizza sauce).

Locations

There are a few Anchor Bar locations in the Buffalo area:
1047 Main Street, Buffalo, NY
4300 Maple Road, Amherst, NY
6635 Transit Road, Williamsville, NY

hofbrauhaus buffalo new york restaurants

Hofbräuhaus

Are you in search of a unique European-style experience in upstate New York? The Hofbräuhaus in Buffalo is the place to be for an authentic Bavarian beer hall atmosphere and fresh-brewed craft beers. This iconic landmark offers patrons an authentic atmosphere along with traditional dishes and drinks from Germany itself. With its old-world decor and original brewery artifacts, it’s easy to lose yourself in the wonderful sights and sounds of Bavaria right here in America. From delicious food to thirst-quenching beers brewed on-site, you have to experience all that Hofbräuhaus has to offer.

Visitors can get an authentic Oktoberfest experience that fits just as nicely into the cold Buffalo winter as it does at its homeland celebrations each Fall. From award-winning house brews to delicious traditional German dishes, Hofbräuhaus offers something for every kind of beer lover or cultural cuisine enthusiast out there.

Suggested Menu Items

Kartoffelsuppe (creamy soup with sliced sausage and fresh vegetables), Riesenbrezen Combo (jumbo pretzel served with Obatzda cheese, sweet mustard, and onion mustard), Paniertes Jägerschnitzel (breaded pork cutlet pan-fried and served with homemade spätzle and mushroom sauce, garnished with crispy onions and cranberries), Wurstplatte (Vienna-style Frankfurter, pork and chicken sausages, served with imported sauerkraut, mashed potatoes, and onion mustard), or Sauerbraten (pot roast served Bavarian style with red wine sauce, vegetable strips, homemade spätzle, and red cabbage). Save room for some Apfelstrudel (imported from Bavaria and topped with a rich vanilla sauce) or Käsekuchen (Bavarian cheesecake with raspberry sauce). Wash it all down with a Hofbräuhaus Original (Lager, 5.1% ABV 24 IBU), Dunkel (Dark Lager, 5.5% ABV 23 IBU), Hefe Weizen (Wheat Beer, 5.1% ABV 14 IBU), Maibock (Bock Beer, 7.2% ABV 31 IBU), or an Oktoberfestbier (German Style, 6.3% ABV 26 IBU).

Location

Hofbräuhaus is located at 190 Scott Street in Buffalo, NY.

glen park tavern buffalo new york restaurant

Glen Park Tavern

Nestled in the charming village of Williamsville, the iconic Glen Park Tavern has been a favorite destination for foodies and locals alike since 1887. This century-old tavern has been a favorite spot among locals and visitors alike, offering gastronomic delights, refreshing drinks, and a cozy ambiance that makes you feel right at home. 

From the moment you walk in, you feel like you have stepped back in time, and this is what makes Glen Park Tavern unique. One of the most alluring features of the tavern is its ornate wooden bar, which serves an array of classic cocktails, craft beers, and a well-curated wine selection.

The menu at Glen Park Tavern boasts a selection of classic American comfort food, with a focus on fresh, locally-sourced ingredients. From the succulent Buffalo chicken wings to the mouth-watering beef on weck, each dish is crafted with finesse and attention to detail. 

From its rich history and delicious food to its cozy atmosphere and community involvement, it’s easy to see why the Glen Park Tavern is the best-kept secret in Williamsville. It’s a place where memories are made, and old friends are reunited, and a perfect spot to enjoy your favorite meal and drink while wrapped in the Tavern’s unique and inviting ambiance. If you’re looking for the ultimate dining experience in Western New York, then be sure to visit the Glen Park Tavern in Williamsville.

Suggested Menu Items

Lobster Bisque, Yummy Tavern Wings (tossed in tavern-made sauces – mild, medium, hot, or BBQ, citrus chipotle, Cajun and Sicilian), Cajun Cod, Whitefish Francais (fresh fish sautéed golden brown in tavern Parmesan egg batter and topped with a garlic lemon wine sauce), Main Street Meatloaf, Tavern Baby Back Ribs (topped with tavern cannonball BBQ sauce), Hand Carved Turkey Dinner (served with choice of potato, stuffing, and fresh veggie), The William Mattar (4 roaster chicken wings dressed in the sauce of your choice, a 4-ounce Beef on Weck, and 4 ounces of tavern made French fries), Greek Souvlaki, Buffalo’s Beef on Weak, The Glen Park Signature Burger (8 oz or 12 oz served on a Costanzo roll), The Garrison (6 oz. of tenderloin fillet served with your choice of tavern made fries, sweet fries or chips).

Location

Glen Park Tavern is located at 5507 Main Street in Williamsville, NY.

Schwabl’s

If you’re looking for a truly unique and delicious taste of Buffalo, then look no further than a Beef on Weck at Schwabl’s! This beloved Buffalo sandwich is one that the locals swear by, and will give you an unforgettable culinary experience. The combination of prime-cut roast beef piled high on top of a kimmelweck roll makes for an iconic meal that has gained international recognition – just ask any Buffalonian their favorite place to grab this dish and they’ll point you to Schwabl’s. Not only does this eatery offer succulent cuts of premium quality beef and incredible flavour in every bite, but it also offers diners a premier atmosphere with plenty of old-world charm.

Whether you’re an avid foodie or just someone who enjoys discovering new delicacies around the globe – Schwabl’s in Buffalo will not disappoint!

Suggested Menu Items

Roast Beef Sandwich On Kümmelweck (robust 1/2 lb. serving of in-house roasted beef served on kümmelweck), and Bavarian Style Pretzel Sticks (light and flaky with a crisp shell, served With Homemade Beer Cheese Or Honey Mustard dipping sauces). Wash it all down with a Tom & Jerry (lightly sweetened egg batter, with dark rum and brandy mixture added, then finished with hot water and a sprinkle of nutmeg).

Location

Schwabl’s is located at 789 Center Road in West Seneca, NY.

Mulberry Italian Ristorante

If you’re visiting Buffalo and want a delicious Italian dining experience, then a meal at Mulberry Italian Ristorante needs to be added to your itinerary. This quaint restaurant on the south side of Buffalo is a favourite among locals and visitors alike and serves up some of the best traditional Italian cuisines in the city. Their warm atmosphere welcomes everyone who steps through their doors, and the delicious cuisine will have your mouth watering before you even take your first bite. With classic dishes made from scratch using fresh ingredients, plus an ever-changing selection of specials crafted by talented chefs each day, Mulberry Italian Ristorante has something to tantalize any taste bud.

It comes as no surprise that the folks at Mulberry Italian Ristorante are big fans of the Buffalo Bills – and the feeling is mutual! Linebacker Von Miller thinks Mulberry’s has some of the best Italian food in Western New York:

Mulberry’s even has dishes named after some of the Buffalo Bills:
• Tre White Spicy BBQ Wings – Tre’Davious White
• Tremaine’s Toast – Tremaine Edmunds
• Josh Allen Dual Threat Surf n Turf Agnolotti – Josh Allen

Whether it’s a quick business lunch or a romantic dinner with your loved one – they have something on their menu to suit every palate! The food is mouth-watering, the service is fantastic, and the ambiance will make you feel as though you’ve been transported to Italy.

Suggested Menu Items

Arancini (Nduja, fontina, tomato sauce, basil pesto), Tremaine’s Toast (grilled ciabatta, sausage, creamy stracchino cheese, arugula), Jack West Ribeye (22oz bone-in cowboy steak, cracked garlic butter creamer potatoes, vegetable), Pasta Martoche (crab, asparagus, vodka sauce, baby shell pasta), Gnocchi Mulberry (ricotta gnocchi, sausage, hot peppers, mozzarella), or the Josh Allen Dual Threat Surf n Turf Agnolotti (double stuffed agnolotti – Short rib, mushroom, and fontina on one side – Rock shrimp, mascarpone, and lemon on the other – with chive butter sauce, fresh grated Romano, lemon zest, cracked pepper). Save room for some Officer Brennan Cheesecake (NY Style Cheesecake topped with melba sauce drizzle), Tiramisu (traditional), or Peanut Butter Pie (graham crust, chocolate drizzle).

Location

Mulberry Italian Ristorante is located at 64 Jackson Avenue in Lackawanna, NY.

Enjoy Eating Your Way Around Buffalo

Buffalo is a city that’s full of surprises. Not only is it home to some delicious food, but there are also plenty of great places to visit and things to do. We hope our list of 9 Amazing Eateries in Buffalo helps to make your next visit even more enjoyable. If you ever find yourself in the area, be sure to check out some of these spots – you won’t regret it!

Cheers,
Big Daddy

If you are a PR agency or brand and would like me to review a travel destination, vehicle, restaurant, product or service, please send me an email.


Craig Silva

Craig is a passionate and seasoned travel, food, and lifestyle writer, whose words paint vivid pictures of the world's most captivating destinations. His work not only inspires others to embark on their own adventures but also fosters a deep appreciation for the beauty and diversity of our world. He captures the essence of each locale, offering readers a glimpse into the cultures, landscapes, cuisine, and experiences that make travel so enriching. Craig is a member of the Society of American Travel Writers (SATW) and the International Travel Writers Alliance (ITWA). If you are a PR agency or brand and would like Craig to review a travel destination, vehicle, restaurant, product or service, please send him an email.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.